Beste GitLab-Alternativen Kurzliste
Hier ist meine Kurzliste der besten GitLab-Alternativen:
DevOps-Plattformen helfen Teams dabei, Code zu verwalten, Builds zu automatisieren und Software zuverlässiger auszuliefern.
Du könntest nach einer GitLab-Alternative suchen, wenn du auf begrenzte Integrationsmöglichkeiten, langsame Pipelines oder eine Benutzeroberfläche stößt, die nicht zu den Workflows deines Teams passt. Der Wechsel von Tools ist nie einfach, aber die richtige Plattform kann die Zusammenarbeit verbessern, Deployments beschleunigen und konsistentere Entwicklungspraktiken fördern.
Ich habe mit Engineering- und DevOps-Teams zusammengearbeitet, um Plattformen anhand realer Projektanforderungen zu evaluieren – vom Skalieren von CI/CD bis hin zur Verbesserung der Developer Experience. Dieser Leitfaden basiert auf diesen Erfahrungen und hilft dir, ein Tool auszuwählen, das zur Arbeitsweise deines Teams passt.
Was ist GitLab?
GitLab ist eine DevOps-Plattform, die den gesamten Softwareentwicklungszyklus unterstützt. Sie wird vor allem von Entwicklern, Projektmanagern und IT-Operations-Teams genutzt, die Zusammenarbeit und Effizienz verbessern möchten.
Funktionen wie Quellcodeverwaltung, Continuous Integration und Issue-Tracking unterstützen bei der Organisation von Projekten und steigern die Produktivität des Teams. Insgesamt bietet GitLab eine einheitliche Plattform, die den Entwicklungsprozess für dein Team vereinfacht.
Warum du unseren Software-Reviews vertrauen kannst
Seit 2023 testen und bewerten wir SaaS-Entwicklungssoftware. Da wir selbst Technikexperten sind, wissen wir, wie entscheidend und schwierig die Auswahl der richtigen Software ist. Wir investieren viel Recherche, um unserer Zielgruppe fundierte Software-Kaufentscheidungen zu ermöglichen.
Wir haben mehr als 2.000 Tools für verschiedene SaaS-Entwicklungsanwendungen getestet und über 1.000 ausführliche Software-Reviews verfasst. Erfahre wie wir Transparenz gewährleisten & informiere dich über unsere Software-Testmethodik.
Beste GitLab-Alternativen Zusammenfassung
Diese Vergleichstabelle fasst die Preisinformationen meiner Top-GitLab-Alternativen zusammen, damit du die beste Lösung für dein Budget und deine geschäftlichen Anforderungen findest.
| Tool | Best For | Trial Info | Price | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Best for AI-assisted coding | Free plan available | From $4/user/month | Website | |
| 2 | Best for Jira integration | Free plan available | From $3.65/user/month (for 5 users) | Website | |
| 3 | Best for CI/CD automation | Free download available | Free to use | Website | |
| 4 | Best for Atlassian pipelines | 30-day free trial | From $1,200 | Website | |
| 5 | Best for Microsoft integration | Free demo available | From $6/user/month | Website | |
| 6 | Best for AWS integration | Free tier available | Pricing upon request | Website | |
| 7 | Best for open-source projects | Free demo available | Pricing upon request | Website | |
| 8 | Best for fast build testing | Free plan + demo available | From $15/month | Website | |
| 9 | Best for continuous integration | 14-day free trial + demo available | From $15/month (billed annually) | Website | |
| 10 | Best for distributed version control | Free demo available | Free to use | Website |
-
Site24x7
Visit WebsiteThis is an aggregated rating for this tool including ratings from Crozdesk users and ratings from other sites.4.6 -
GitHub Actions
Visit WebsiteThis is an aggregated rating for this tool including ratings from Crozdesk users and ratings from other sites.4.8 -
Docker
Visit WebsiteThis is an aggregated rating for this tool including ratings from Crozdesk users and ratings from other sites.4.6
Beste GitLab-Alternativen Bewertungen
Unten findest du meine ausführlichen Zusammenfassungen der besten GitLab-Alternativen aus meiner Kurzliste. Meine Reviews bieten dir einen detaillierten Einblick in die wichtigsten Features, Vor- und Nachteile, Integrationen und Anwendungsfälle jedes Tools, sodass du die beste Wahl für dich treffen kannst.
GitHub is a development platform that caters to software developers, project managers, and IT teams. It provides source code management, version control, and collaboration tools to enhance project efficiency and team coordination.
Why it's a good GitLab alternative: GitHub's AI-assisted coding helps your team write code faster and with fewer errors. The Copilot feature offers code suggestions and automates repetitive tasks, enhancing productivity.
GitHub's user-friendly interface and extensive community support make it accessible for all team members. Its focus on AI integration sets it apart, providing a unique edge over GitLab.
Standout features & integrations:
Features include a customizable project board, code review tools, and issue tracking. The project board lets you manage tasks visually, making it easier to track progress. Code review tools facilitate team collaboration and ensure code quality, while issue tracking helps prioritize and resolve problems efficiently.
Integrations include Slack, Trello, Jira, Asana, Microsoft Teams, Zendesk, Heroku, AWS, Google Cloud, and Azure.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Large community support
- Extensive documentation
- Strong code review features
Cons:
- Limited built-in CI/CD tools
- Complex permission settings
BitBucket is a web-based version control repository hosting service for source code and development projects. It's mainly used by software developers and teams who need to manage their code repositories and collaborate effectively.
Why it's a good GitLab alternative: BitBucket's strong integration with Jira makes it a great choice if your team uses Jira for project management. The ability to link issues directly to commits helps keep your development and project management in sync. BitBucket also offers unlimited private repositories, which is ideal for teams who need privacy. Its focus on supporting multiple version control systems, including Git and Mercurial, adds flexibility compared to GitLab.
Standout features & integrations:
Features include branch permissions, smart mirroring, and pull request functionality. Branch permissions allow you to control access to specific parts of your code, enhancing security. Smart mirroring speeds up cloning and fetching from remote repositories, which helps your team save time.
Integrations include Jira, Trello, Slack, Microsoft Teams, Bamboo, Jenkins, Crucible, Fisheye, Confluence, and HipChat.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Advanced branch permissions
- Supports multiple version control systems
- Unlimited private repositories
Cons:
- Learning curve for new users
- Requires an Atlassian account
Jenkins is an open-source automation server that is widely used by developers and IT teams to build, test, and deploy software. It supports continuous integration and continuous delivery (CI/CD), making it a key tool for automating the software development process.
Why it's a good GitLab alternative: Jenkins excels in CI/CD automation, providing extensive support for building and deploying applications. Its flexible pipeline system allows you to customize workflows to fit your team's needs.
Jenkins offers a vast library of plugins, which enhances its functionality and adaptability. Unlike GitLab, Jenkins is highly customizable, allowing you to tailor the automation server to your specific requirements.
Standout features & integrations:
Features include workflow automation, distributed builds, and a rich plugin ecosystem. Workflow automation helps you manage complex build processes with ease. Distributed builds enable you to scale your CI/CD processes across multiple machines, improving efficiency.
Integrations include GitHub, Bitbucket, GitLab, Docker, AWS, Azure, Google Cloud, Slack, Jira, and Kubernetes.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Extensive plugin library
- Flexible pipeline system
- Highly customizable workflows
Cons:
- Requires maintenance and updates
- Steep learning curve
Bamboo is a continuous integration and deployment server built for teams using Bitbucket and Jira. It’s designed to help dev teams automate builds, tests, and releases with tight integration across the Atlassian ecosystem.
Why Bamboo is a good GitLab alternative: Bamboo works best if your team already uses Atlassian tools and wants everything to stay in one place. It supports build plans that connect directly to Jira issues, so your team can track progress and releases in real time.
Built-in deployment projects make it easier to manage environments and control release workflows. It also gives you visibility into the full delivery pipeline without needing to switch between tools.
Standout features & integrations:
Features include custom-built agents that let you scale capacity based on your team's needs. You can run parallel batch tests and manage deployment triggers based on successful builds. Built-in permissions give you control over who can deploy, edit, or view build results.
Integrations include Bitbucket, Jira Software, Fisheye, Crucible, Clover, Crowd, Git, and Mercurial.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Scales with additional agents
- Clear release and deployment tracking
- Easy setup with Jira and Bitbucket
Cons:
- Some config tasks need scripting
- Limited plugin marketplace
Azure DevOps is a cloud-based DevOps service for planning, developing, testing, and delivering software. It's used by developers, project managers, and IT professionals who require a comprehensive suite of tools to manage their software development lifecycle.
Why it's a good GitLab alternative: Azure DevOps offers deep integration with Microsoft's ecosystem, making it a solid choice if your team relies on Microsoft products. It provides extensive support for CI/CD pipelines, helping automate your software delivery process.
The tool includes Azure Repos, Azure Pipelines, and Azure Boards, which together offer version control, build automation, and project management. These features make it a versatile platform for teams seeking a unified solution for development and deployment.
Standout features & integrations:
Features include release management, test plans, and artifact management. Release management automates deployments and tracks releases efficiently, while test plans help manage and execute tests to ensure software quality. Artifact management stores and organizes packages, making code sharing and reuse easier across projects.
Integrations include Microsoft Teams, GitHub, Slack, Jira, Jenkins, Docker, Kubernetes, Visual Studio, Eclipse, and ServiceNow.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Supports multiple programming languages
- Scalable for large teams
- Versatile project management tools
Cons:
- Can be complex for small projects
- Requires technical expertise to set up
AWS CodeCommit is a fully managed source control service that hosts secure Git-based repositories. It's aimed at developers and IT teams who need a scalable and secure environment for collaborative code development.
Why it's a good GitLab alternative: AWS CodeCommit integrates seamlessly with other AWS services, making it ideal if your team already uses AWS. It provides unlimited repositories and scales with your projects, ensuring you never run out of space. The service offers high availability and durability, protecting your code with AWS's infrastructure.
Unlike GitLab, AWS CodeCommit focuses on providing a secure and scalable platform with deep AWS integration.
Standout features & integrations:
Features include automatic scaling, secure access, and high availability. Automatic scaling adjusts resources based on project demands for optimal performance. Secure access manages permissions, while high availability keeps your code accessible with minimal downtime.
Integrations include AWS Lambda, AWS CloudWatch, AWS CodePipeline, AWS CodeBuild, AWS CodeDeploy, Jira, Slack, GitHub, Jenkins, and Bitbucket.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Scalable with project needs
- High availability and durability
- Unlimited repositories
Cons:
- Lacks some advanced features
- Requires AWS knowledge
SourceForge is a web-based platform that provides tools for developers to manage and distribute open-source software projects. It caters to developers and open-source enthusiasts who need a space to collaborate and share their work with the community.
Why it's a good GitLab alternative: SourceForge offers a centralized location for hosting and managing open-source projects, making it ideal if your team focuses on open-source development. It provides project management tools, version control, and bug tracking to help your team stay organized.
SourceForge also offers a community-driven environment, allowing you to connect with other developers and share ideas. Its focus on open-source projects sets it apart from GitLab, which caters to a broader range of development needs.
Standout features & integrations:
Features include project hosting, download statistics, and bug tracking. Project hosting lets your team store and manage code in one central location. Download statistics provide insights into project usage, while bug tracking helps identify and resolve issues to maintain quality.
Integrations include GitHub, Bitbucket, Jira, Jenkins, Slack, Trello, Asana, Confluence, Google Drive, and Microsoft Teams.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Ideal for open-source projects
- Community-driven environment
- Centralized project hosting
Cons:
- Limited advanced features
- Less suited for private projects
CircleCI is a continuous integration and delivery platform used by engineering teams to build, test, and deploy code automatically. It’s built for teams that want to ship software quickly and test frequently across multiple environments.
Why CircleCI is a good GitLab alternative: CircleCI focuses on speeding up build and test times so your team can get feedback fast. It runs jobs in parallel and lets you split tests across multiple containers.
You can use workflows to control job sequencing and handle complex pipelines. Configuration happens in your repo, so your team always works from the same setup.
Standout features & integrations:
Features include resource classes that let you customize CPU and RAM for each job. You can use caching to speed up future builds by reusing previous steps. The insights dashboard helps you track build performance over time.
Integrations include GitHub, Bitbucket, Slack, Jira, Docker Hub, AWS, Azure, GCP, Datadog, and Sentry.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Fast feedback with parallel jobs
- Config stays in version control
- Good performance with heavy workloads
Cons:
- Debugging jobs aren’t always simple
- Can take time to learn the config
TeamCity is a continuous integration and build management system designed for developers and IT teams to automate and optimize their software delivery processes. It supports building, testing, and deploying applications efficiently.
Why it's a good GitLab alternative: TeamCity excels in continuous integration, providing detailed build history and real-time feedback on build processes. Its parallel builds feature allows your team to run multiple builds simultaneously, saving time. The customizable build pipeline lets you tailor processes to fit your team's workflow.
Unlike GitLab, TeamCity offers extensive support for various build runners and version control systems, enhancing flexibility in your development environment.
Standout features & integrations:
Features include build failure conditions, cloud-based build agents, and agent management. Build failure conditions help detect and address issues early to maintain quality. Cloud-based agents offer scalable resources, while agent management lets you control and optimize your build environment.
Integrations include GitHub, Bitbucket, GitLab, Azure DevOps, Slack, Jira, Docker, Kubernetes, AWS, and Google Cloud.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Detailed build history
- Supports parallel builds
- Customizable build pipelines
Cons:
- Initial setup complexity
- Requires configuration knowledge
Mercurial is a distributed version control system designed for developers who need a fast and efficient way to manage code changes across multiple projects. It caters to teams looking to maintain robust control over their source code in a distributed environment.
Why it's a good GitLab alternative: Mercurial offers a simpler command-line interface, which can be easier for your team to learn and use effectively. It supports distributed workflows, allowing team members to work independently and merge changes seamlessly.
Mercurial's scalability makes it suitable for large projects with many contributors. Unlike GitLab, Mercurial focuses on providing a lightweight and efficient version control system without the added complexity of a full DevOps platform.
Standout features & integrations:
Features include efficient branching, lightweight tagging, and fast performance. Efficient branching allows you to create and manage branches quickly, enhancing collaboration. Lightweight tagging helps you organize code versions without adding overhead. Fast performance ensures that your team can handle large repositories and complex histories with ease.
Integrations include TortoiseHg, Bitbucket, Phabricator, Kiln, RhodeCode, Kallithea, Heptapod, Bamboo, Jenkins, and Atlassian Crucible.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Scalable for large projects
- Supports distributed workflows
- Simple command-line interface
Cons:
- Fewer third-party integrations
- Limited built-in collaboration tools
Weitere GitLab-Alternativen
Hier findest du einige weitere GitLab-Alternativen, die es nicht auf meine Kurzliste geschafft haben, aber dennoch einen Blick wert sind:
- Travis CI
For GitHub CI pipelines
- Jira
For project management
- RhodeCode
For enterprise security
- Tuleap
For agile project management
- Plastic SCM
For game development teams
- Perforce
For large-scale projects
- IBM Rational ClearCase
For complex software builds
- Launchpad
For open-source collaboration
- Subversion (SVN)
For centralized version control
- Crucible (by Atlassian)
For peer code reviews
Auswahlkriterien für GitLab-Alternativen
Bei der Auswahl der besten GitLab-Alternativen für diese Liste habe ich gängige Bedürfnisse und Schmerzpunkte der Käufer in Bezug auf DevOps-Plattformen berücksichtigt, wie Skalierbarkeit und Integrationsmöglichkeiten. Ich habe außerdem das folgende Framework verwendet, um meine Bewertung strukturiert und fair zu gestalten:
Kernfunktionen (25% der Gesamtbewertung)
Um in dieser Liste berücksichtigt zu werden, musste jede Lösung diese typischen Anwendungsbereiche abdecken:
- Verwaltung von Code-Repositories
- Continuous Integration und Delivery
- Versionskontrolle
- Issue-Tracking
- Zusammenarbeitstools
Zusätzliche herausragende Funktionen (25% der Gesamtwertung)
Um die Auswahl weiter einzugrenzen, habe ich auch nach einzigartigen Funktionen gesucht, wie zum Beispiel:
- Erweiterte Analysen und Berichte
- KI-gesteuerte Code-Vorschläge
- Integrierte Sicherheitsüberprüfung
- Anpassbare Workflows
- Unterstützung für Multi-Cloud-Bereitstellungen
Benutzerfreundlichkeit (10% der Gesamtwertung)
Um ein Gefühl für die Benutzerfreundlichkeit jedes Systems zu bekommen, habe ich Folgendes berücksichtigt:
- Intuitive Benutzeroberfläche
- Einfache Navigation
- Anpassungsoptionen
- Barrierefreiheitsfunktionen
- Mobile Kompatibilität
Einarbeitung (10% der Gesamtwertung)
Um das Onboarding-Erlebnis jeder Plattform zu bewerten, habe ich Folgendes in Betracht gezogen:
- Verfügbarkeit von Trainingsvideos
- Interaktive Produkttouren
- Onboarding-Vorlagen
- Webinare und Live-Sitzungen
- Chatbot-Unterstützung
Kundensupport (10% der Gesamtwertung)
Um die Kundensupportdienste jedes Softwareanbieters zu beurteilen, habe ich Folgendes bedacht:
- 24/7 Verfügbarkeit
- Mehrere Support-Kanäle
- Reaktionszeit
- Technische Fachkompetenz
- Verfügbarkeit von Self-Service-Ressourcen
Preis-Leistungs-Verhältnis (10% der Gesamtwertung)
Um das Preis-Leistungs-Verhältnis jeder Plattform zu bewerten, habe ich Folgendes berücksichtigt:
- Transparente Preisgestaltung
- Funktionen-im-Verhältnis-zum-Preis
- Skalierbarkeit der Preismodelle
- Rabatte für langfristige Verträge
- Verfügbarkeit einer kostenlosen Testversion
Kundenbewertungen (10% der Gesamtwertung)
Um einen Gesamteindruck der Kundenzufriedenheit zu bekommen, habe ich beim Lesen von Kundenbewertungen auf Folgendes geachtet:
- Gesamte Zufriedenheitsbewertung
- Feedback zum Funktionsumfang
- Kommentare zur Zuverlässigkeit
- Erfahrungen mit dem Support
- Rückmeldung zur Benutzerfreundlichkeit
Warum nach einer GitLab-Alternative suchen?
GitLab ist zwar eine gute Wahl als DevOps-Plattform, doch es gibt viele Gründe, warum einige Nutzer nach Alternativen zu Git suchen. Sie könnten nach einer GitLab-Alternative Ausschau halten, weil…
- Sie eine bessere Integration mit bestimmten Tools benötigen
- Ihr Team fortschrittlichere Analysen braucht
- Sie sich eine einfachere Benutzeroberfläche wünschen
- Ihr Projekt höhere Skalierbarkeit verlangt
- Sie eine bessere geografische Verfügbarkeit benötigen
- Ihr Team flexiblere Preismodelle wünscht
Wenn einer dieser Punkte auf Sie zutrifft, sind Sie hier genau richtig. Meine Liste enthält mehrere DevOps-Plattformen, die für Teams, die bei GitLab auf diese Herausforderungen stoßen, besser geeignet sind und alternative Lösungen bieten.
Wichtige GitLab-Funktionen
Hier sind einige der wichtigsten Funktionen von GitLab, um Ihnen den Vergleich zu alternativen Lösungen zu erleichtern:
- Planungswerkzeuge: Verwalten Sie Portfolios und verfolgen Sie den Fortschritt mit Epics und Meilensteinen.
- Quellcodeverwaltung: Ermöglichen Sie Versionskontrolle und Zusammenarbeit am Code.
- Kontinuierliche Integration/Bereitstellung: Automatisieren Sie Test- und Bereitstellungsprozesse.
- Sicherheit und Compliance: Verwalten Sie die Sicherheit in der Software-Lieferkette.
- Beobachtbarkeit und Messung: Erhalten Sie Einblicke in die Projektleistung.
- Aufgabenmanagement: Organisieren Sie Aufgaben, indem Sie Probleme in kleinere Komponenten unterteilen.
- Problem-Analysen: Analysieren Sie Probleme auf Gruppenebene für umsetzbare Erkenntnisse.
- Jira-Integration: Verbinden Sie sich mit Jira für ein erweitertes Projektmanagement.
- Zeiterfassung: Erfassen Sie die auf Aufgaben und Merge Requests verwendete Zeit.
- GitLab Pages: Stellen Sie statische Websites mit Funktionen wie benutzerdefinierten Domains und HTTPS-Unterstützung bereit.
Wie geht es weiter?
Steigern Sie Ihr SaaS-Wachstum und Ihre Führungskompetenzen. Abonnieren Sie unseren Newsletter für die neuesten Einblicke von CTOs und aufstrebenden Tech-Führungskräften. Wir unterstützen Sie dabei, intelligenter zu skalieren und stärker zu führen – mit Leitfäden, Ressourcen und Strategien von Top-Expert:innen!
